Variable | Methadonea | Bup (oral)b | Bup (inject)c | Nal (oral)d | Nal (inject)e | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Mean of ranks sums (N) | (χ2, df, p-value) | Mean of ranks sums (N) | (χ2, df, p-value) | Mean of ranks sums (N) | (χ2, df, p-value) | Mean of ranks sums (N) | (χ2, df, p-value) | Mean of ranks sums (N) | (χ2, df, p-value) | |
System | ||||||||||
YLS | 62.9 (37) | 0.02 (1), p = 0.895 | 59.7 (35) | 0.36 (1), p = 0.550 | 51.9 (42) | 1.32 (1), p = 0.251 | 51.5 (32) | 1.05 (1), p = 0.305 | 56.3 (33) | 0.36 (1), p = 0.546 |
CMHC | 63.8 (85) | 63.8 (85) | 59.4 (77) | 58.1 (76) | 60.3 (80) | |||||
Rurality | ||||||||||
Less rural | 73.8 (30) | 0.04 (1), p = 0.838 | 68.6 (30) | 0.22 (1), p = 0.637 | 75.4 (30) | 0.44 (1), p = 0.507 | 71.4 (30) | 0 (1), p = 0.984 | 70.1 (30) | 0.02 (1), p = 0.881 |
More rural | 72.1 (111) | 72.4 (109) | 70.3 (109) | 71.5 (109) | 71.3 (108) | |||||
Age | ||||||||||
18–25 | 46.8 (50) | 20.16 (5), p = 0.001 | 51.2 (50) | 11.90 (5), p = 0.036 | 49.0 (50) | 13.65 (5), p = 0.018 | 52.2 (50) | 9.87 (5), p = 0.079 | 49.9 (50) | 8.45 (5), p = 0.133 |
26–35 | 71.5 (41) | 69.9 (41) | 71.6 (41) | 65.3 (41) | 67.7 (41) | |||||
36–45 | 90.2 (37) | 83.1 (35) | 80.5 (35) | 84.8 (36) | 80.2 (35) | |||||
46–55 | 59.9 (26) | 65.5 (26) | 65.9 (26) | 72.4 (26) | 70.2 (25) | |||||
56–65 | 73.7 (50) | 75.7 (50) | 77.0 (50) | 77.2 (51) | 84.8 (50) | |||||
66+ | 123.7 (3) | 121.7 (3) | 128.8 (3) | 91.5 (3) | 89.5 (3) | |||||
Gender | ||||||||||
Male | 72.0 (115) | 1.82 (2), p = 0.403 | 69.4 (113) | 4.16 (2), p = 0.125 | 71.5 (114) | 4.84 (2), p = 0.089 | 70.9 (115) | 4.07 (2), p = 0.131 | 69.5 (114) | 4.50 (2), p = 0.106 |
Female | 76.4 (25) | 81.4 (25) | 71.5 (24) | 74.4 (23) | 78.0 (23) | |||||
Other | 102.7 (3) | 106.7 (3) | 121.5 (3) | 116.7 (3) | 114.0 (3) | |||||
Race | ||||||||||
White | 74.0 (136) | 0.27 (1), p = 0.605 | 72.4 (134) | 0.02 (1), p = 0.884 | 72.6 (134) | 0.02 (1), p = 0.886 | 72.4 (134) | 0.03 (1), p = 0.870 | 72.2 (133) | 0.05 (1), p = 0.825 |
Racial minority | 67.1 (10) | 74.3 (10) | 70.8 (10) | 74.5 (10) | 69.4 (10) | |||||
Ethnicity | ||||||||||
Non-Hispanic | 72.7 (135) | 0.76 (1), p = 0.385 | 71.6 (133) | 0.63 (1), p = 0.429 | 71.3 (133) | 0.17 (1), p = 0.682 | 71.3 (133) | 0.13 (1), p = 0.722 | 71.1 (132) | 0.53 (1), p = 0.465 |
Hispanic | 60.1 (8) | 60.3 (8) | 65.6 (8) | 66.3 (8) | 60.9 (8) | |||||
Time at Position | ||||||||||
<1 year | 79.3 (18) | 1.33 (3), p = 0.721 | 82.2 (17) | 2.42 (3), p = 0.490 | 69.4 (17) | 0.27 (3), p = 0.965 | 68.5 (18) | 2.27 (3), p = 0.518 | 74.2 (18) | 2.42 (3), p = 0.490 |
1–4 years | 71.2 (77) | 68.2 (77) | 72.1 (77) | 69.6 (77) | 67.4 (76) | |||||
5–9 years | 79.8 (19) | 77.9 (18) | 75.0 (18) | 82.5 (18) | 79.6 (17) | |||||
10 + years | 70.5 (23) | 73.4 (23) | 74.2 (23) | 76.4 (22) | 77.8 (23) | |||||
Education | ||||||||||
Some college | 90.3 (3) | 6.96 (4), p = 0.138 | 131.0 (3) | 15.71 (4), p = 0.003 | 98.2 (3) | 8.69 (4), p = 0.069 | 87.8 (2) | 2.63 (4), p = 0.621 | 103.5 (3) | 6.37 (4), p = 0.173 |
Bachelor’s | 64.7 (73) | 61.0 (71) | 63.6 (72) | 67.6 (73) | 64.6 (71) | |||||
Associate’s | 86.0 (2) | 83.0 (2) | 88.3 (2) | 87.8 (2) | 86.0 (2) | |||||
Master’s | 81.8 (59) | 82.0 (59) | 81.8 (58) | 77.1 (58) | 78.5 (58) | |||||
Doctorate | 82.1 (9) | 79.2 (9) | 71.2 (9) | 75.9 (9) | 75.1 (9) | |||||
Job Satisfaction | ||||||||||
Dissatisfied | 68.9 (7) | 1.23 (2), p = 0.542 | 69.3 (7) | 0.56 (2), p = 0.755 | 79.2 (7) | 0.76 (2), p = 0.683 | 79.3 (7) | 0.96 (2), p = 0.620 | 74.9 (7) | 1.09 (2), p = 0.579 |
Neutral | 84.3 (12) | 79.7 (12) | 79.2 (12) | 80.3 (12) | 81.7 (12) | |||||
Satisfied | 72.4 (124) | 71.8 (122) | 71.3 (122) | 71.1 (122) | 70.6 (121) |